Wednesday, August 10, 2022
flickfeast
  • News
  • Reviews
  • Festivals
  • FrightFeast
  • Spotlight
  • Contribute
  • Submissions
    • Advertise on Flickfeast
    • Submit a Film
No Result
View All Result
flickfeast
  • News
  • Reviews
  • Festivals
  • FrightFeast
  • Spotlight
  • Contribute
  • Submissions
    • Advertise on Flickfeast
    • Submit a Film
No Result
View All Result
FLICKFEAST
No Result
View All Result
Home Feature

J. Edgar (2011)

Charlotte Stretch by Charlotte Stretch
January 24, 2012
in Feature, Film Review
14
SHARES
1.4k
VIEWS
Share on FacebookShare on Twitter

Following the huge successes of Catch Me if You Can, The Aviator and now J. Edgar – and with a rumoured Sinatra biopic in the works – Leonardo DiCaprio may be giving Michael Sheen a run for his money as a one-man biopic powerhouse. His turn in Clint Eastwood’s latest movie, playing the charming and (famously) sexually ambiguous head of the FBI, is right up there with some of his very best performances. Sadly it’s not quite enough to make J. Edgar the Oscar shoo-in it clearly strives to be – although it does go some way to redeeming the film.

Hoover’s final years provide the framework of the film, as he dictates his memoirs to a succession of bright-eyed young staffers. It’s a simple device, perhaps not particularly original, but it does in fact work well here – largely because the scenes of an elderly Hoover contain a lot more than just wistful, nostalgic gazes. Even in his twilight years, Hoover bore exactly the same tenacity and devotion to his work and politics that had characterised his early days with the FBI. In terms of Hoover’s career highlights, there’s a focus on the Lindbergh baby kidnapping, which is probably the most interesting aspect of J. Edgar – Eastwood provides a lively, intriguing guide to the birth of the FBI’s most ground-breaking scientific methods, most notably fingerprinting.

You might also like

Nope (2022) – Film Review

Bullet Train (2022) – Film Review

Where The Crawdads Sing – Film Review

Where J. Edgar falls down, though, is in the portrayal of Hoover’s relationship with right-hand man Clyde Tolson (Armie Hammer) – which is unfortunate, since it very clearly posits this is the story’s core. The suggestions of a homosexual undercurrent are hardly subtle – there’s a wrestling scene that’s just a log fire and a spot of full-frontal nudity away from Women in Love – and, as a result, the whole thing ends up looking a bit cheap. Eastwood is desperate for us to spot the repressed desire between these two men – but he needn’t worry, since it’s not exactly hard to miss. It’s a shame so much emphasis is placed on the sex question, as it overtakes any kind of profound emotional connection they might have had. Despite Hammer’s best efforts, we’re never really made to feel very much about Tolson, or exactly why the two men were so close.

Much the same problem occurs with Miss Gandy (Naomi Watts), Hoover’s unswerving loyal secretary. Having sworn off marriage in favour of her career, Gandy has no discernable personal life – which means we never really learn anything about her. Gandy’s interactions with Hoover are stiff, formal, barely hinting at any kind of closeness between them; we are made to simply accept the level of trust that he puts in her. It doesn’t help that Watts herself does so little to flesh out Gandy’s character: her stilted performance in the movie is far weaker than we’ve come to expect from the actress. Judi Dench, playing Edgar’s overbearing mother, puts in a reliably solid performance – but then, this is the kind of role she could in her sleep.

That a couple of the key peripheral characters are so disappointing, however, isn’t quite enough to fully take down a movie like this. In the big-name biopic, it’s the central performance that matters most – and in this respect the film really does deliver. DiCaprio, playing perhaps his weightiest role yet, seals his reputation as one of today’s finest working actors – with hints of even more greatness to come. It’s thanks almost entirely to his remarkable and utterly compelling gravitas that J. Edgar is – despite all its flaws – nonetheless worth watching.

Director: Clint Eastwood
Writer: Dustin Lance Black
Cast: Leonardo Di Caprio, Judi Dench, Naomi Watts, Armie Hammer
Runtime: 137 minutes
Country: USA

Film Rating: ★★★☆☆

Tags: Armie HammerbiopicClint EastwoodhistoricalJ. Edgarjudi denchLeonardo DiCaprioNaomi wattspolitical drama
Charlotte Stretch

Charlotte Stretch

Related Posts

Nope (2022) – Film Review
Film Review

Nope (2022) – Film Review

by Katie Smith-Wong
August 9, 2022
Bullet Train (2022) – Film Review
Film Review

Bullet Train (2022) – Film Review

by Katie Smith-Wong
August 3, 2022
Where The Crawdads Sing – Film Review
Film Review

Where The Crawdads Sing – Film Review

by Dallas King
July 22, 2022
Thor: Love and Thunder (2022) – Film Review
Film Review

Thor: Love and Thunder (2022) – Film Review

by Katie Smith-Wong
July 16, 2022
Minions: The Rise of Gru (2022) – Film Review
Film Review

Minions: The Rise of Gru (2022) – Film Review

by Katie Smith-Wong
June 29, 2022

Recommended

The Young and Prodigious T.S. Spivet (2013)

June 13, 2014

Arriety (2010)

July 26, 2011

Don't miss it

Nope (2022) – Film Review
Film Review

Nope (2022) – Film Review

August 9, 2022
Alone Together (2022) – Film Review
Reviews

Alone Together (2022) – Film Review

August 4, 2022
Bullet Train (2022) – Film Review
Film Review

Bullet Train (2022) – Film Review

August 3, 2022
Anything’s Possible (2022) – Film Review
Reviews

Anything’s Possible (2022) – Film Review

July 31, 2022
Sofa Surfer (2022)
Reviews

Sofa Surfer (2021) – Short Film Review

August 5, 2022
Where The Crawdads Sing – Film Review
Film Review

Where The Crawdads Sing – Film Review

July 22, 2022
flickfeast

Whetting your appetite for cinema with the best film reviews and features since 2009

© Copyright - flickfeast. All Rights Reserved.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • News
  • Reviews
  • Festivals
  • FrightFeast
  • Spotlight
  • Contribute

© Copyright - flickfeast. All Rights Reserved.

Posting....