Written and directed by Hot Summer Nights director Elijah Bynum, Magazine Dreams stars Jonathan Majors as aspiring bodybuilder Killian Maddox and his struggles in achieving his dreams of becoming an International Federation of BodyBuilding and Fitness (IFBB) champion.
Between his shifts at a local supermarket and his bodybuilding competitions to support his disabled grandfather, Killian strives for perfection. In Bynum’s feature, the theme of bodybuilding is not about athleticism but aesthetics so Killian takes extreme lengths to attain the best-looking body he can. Looking up to icon and bodybuilder Brad Vanderhorn (Mike O’Hearn), he maintains a strict diet, works out obsessively and takes steroids to build up his physique. However, his need with attaining physical perfection, partially driven by the glossy magazine pictures of bodybuilders around his room, causes him to lash out from physical contact for fear of the tiniest imperfection. It also plays into the long-established myth that vanity and physical perfection can lead to popularity and long-term success, but Bynum reaffirms its toxic influence within as Majors’ tormented Killian. Unfortunately, this one-dimensional narrative sees certain plot elements such as his tragic family history become an underdeveloped afterthought.
In addition, Killian’s obsessive nature creates an awkwardness and abhorrence to physical contact that sees him quickly antagonise others – they also extinguish any romantic hopes with shy shopgirl Jessie (Haley Bennett) so there is no happy ending in sight for him. His bodybuilding ambitions also see him prioritising his dreams over his future when his ailing health and a violent encounter with racist thugs cannot deter him from competing, creating an intensely discomforting scene that betrays the depth of his obsession.
Unfortunately, this only feeds a sense of self-hatred and isolation that causes Killian’s underlying aggression and frustration in not achieving perfection to build, leading to a slow-burning final act that feels as lost as the protagonist. By the time he accepts his fate, his decline is overwhelmed by hatred and isolation that it makes audiences wonder where can Killian go, let alone entertain the possibility of redemption. In addition to being physically prepared for his upcoming role in Creed 3, Majors pushes himself to the limit to relay Killian’s anguish and internalised lack of confidence. Evoking an anger and primal force in his tormented character, he kicks off 2023 as the year that makes him a bona fide star and future awards nominee.
In his second directorial feature, Bynum’s direction and screenplay focus on Killian’s psychological journey with Adam Arkapaw’s cinematography building up the protagonist’s increasingly intimidating demeanour. Coupled with Jason Hill’s sinister, dramatic score, Magazine Dreams becomes a sustained nightmare that caves under its protagonist’s lofty dreams.
Overall, Bynum’s intense drama doesn’t shy away from the toxic influence of physical perfection that comes across as a raw character study that may have benefitted from a tighter narrative. However, its brutality and psychological turmoil linger to devastating effect, thanks to Majors’ staggering performance.
Rating: 




Director: Elijah Bynum
Stars: Jonathan Majors, Haley Bennett, Mike O’Hearn, Taylour Paige, Harrison Page, Harriet Sansom Harris
Runtime: 124 minutes
Country: USA













