When I looked through the CPH PIX film festival programme to pick out the movies I wanted to see, and came across a South Korean movie starring Isabelle Huppert, I thought, “Hey, say no more! I’m in!” How could a Korean movie with one of the greatest French actresses be anything but exotic and interesting?
It seems like a no-brainer. Almost any kind of Korean story with Isabelle Huppert in it would be interesting almost by default. Yet director Sang-soo Hong manages to produce something so spectacularly dull that he ought to receive some kind of award for it.
There is no story, per se. Post-structuralism has also come to Korea, and apparently a lot of current movie-makers, both in the West and in the East, find traditional story structure to be old hat. Personally I am a traditionalist in that area; when I go see a movie I really prefer a clear conflict, and a beginning, middle and end to the tale. I think this is the least you can ask for.
But more and more often it seems that a lot of directors (and their writers, if they don’t write it themselves) fall into one of two categories: either they are just too incompetent to be able to create a coherent plot, or they are too bloody artistic to bother with one. Often, even the latter smells to me like incompetence, but I must acknowledge that a lot of directors are interested in untraditional modes of movie-making, and in principle I certainly support experimentalism; it’s just that it very rarely actually works.
But maybe Sang-soo Hong is not an experimentalist at all; maybe he’s just interested in snippets of tales, and small-talk and the subtle nuances of social intercourse. Because that is what we get in this movie. We get three different versions of the same situation (it cannot be called a story) at the same location; in three segments, Isabelle Huppert plays three different characters who all check in to a bed&breakfast at a sleepy Korean holiday resort, where most of the rest of the small cast (a neighbor and his wife, an illicit lover, and a lifeguard) all play the same roles in the three segments.
So, in three different versions, we see how Isabelle and the others interact, just being there, smoking, small-talking, having tiny tiffs, being a bit unfaithful, losing and finding things. I am sorry to say that I was bored through most of it. I do admit, though, that it was interesting to see how the Koreans found Huppert’s character exotic and attractive, always making her the center of attention; perhaps this attitude echoes that of the director’s, and if so I do not disagree with him. In some ways I can understand why he did three little short movies; if I was a director with access to Huppert, I would also try to use her as much as possible.
I am sure some people found this to be a lovely collection of twee feel-good meditations; a many-coloured quilt of tiny jealousies and desires and innuendo, but it was too little; to insubstantial, to be of much interest to this reviewer.
Director: Sang-soo Hong
Cast: Isabelle Huppert, Junsang Yu, Yumi Jung, Hae-hyo Kwon, So-ri Moon, Sung Keun Moon, Yeo-jeong Yoon
Runtime: 89 min.
Country: South Korea
Film Rating: 















