Writer-director Zach Cregger first made his splash on the cinematic horror scene with his 2022 feature Barbarian. Although celebrated for its dark humour and suspense building, this critic was a rare voice of dissent, finding the film to be more style than substance. Which is why it’s so invigorating to say that Cregger’s newest film, Weapons, is superb! Retaining the eloquent direction of Barbarian, the storytelling unweaves its mystery with chilling delicacy, peeling back the layers of its twisted narrative with the slow, horrific precision of a butcher’s knife.
The premise is brilliant: One night, at 2:17am, in the town of Maybrook, seventeen children from the same third grade classroom woke up, ran out their front doors, and vanished into the night. Despite a month of rigorous investigation amid townwide speculation, no leads have been found and anxieties remain skyhigh. As Maybrook is forced to resume its previous routines, the lingering enigma of that night drives an ensemble of characters into searching for the truth for themselves.
Fans of Magnolia will recognise how Cregger and team choose to tell their story. Rather than follow a linear structure, the film jumps throughout its narrative, retelling the story via the perspectives of various characters. Among them are Justine Gandy (Julia Garner), the young, stressed teacher of the kids who went missing, Archer (Josh Brolin), a distraught father of one of the missing children, and the meek Alex (Cary Christopher), the one child from Justine’s class who didn’t disappear. Each of them have been affected by this mystery and their search for answers drives the story, the tension remaining thick enough to slash through.
By adopting this multi-perspective method rather than a more traditional path, Cregger continually examines the inherent intricacies of the central puzzle, carefully adding more pieces to fill the picture as each new perspective brings about fresh information. On the downside, this causes the script to show its hand too early, as the midpoint effectively shows what happened even if it doesn’t show how. However, it still fundamentally basks in the terrifying uncertainty and lingering anxiety that such an incident can cause across a whole community. Telling the story this way not only emphasises the widespread panic, grounding it in a chillingly personal way, but keeps the proverbial wound fresh, heightening the ice cold atmosphere.
Although this script is more plot than character driven, the characters are given a degree of depth by this non-linear format. The panic is palpable among the residents of Maybrook and they need an easy answer to an impossible question. Justine bears the brunt of this, as, via the occam’s razor principle, she’s what connects all the missing children. Her troubled past is scrutinised over her good heart, making her a scapegoat for the town’s deepest fears. Archer leads the charge, in part because he thinks he didn’t show his son enough affection, showcasing Archer as a man whose toxic masculinity is rattled by this tragedy. When the film shifts to young Alex’s viewpoint, we are treated to a character who proves to be truly isolated in more ways than just being an apparent sole survivor. The character layers are created by this storytelling choice, with Creggar and team crafting considerable empathy for them in the process.
Communal trauma is one of the most prominent themes to emerge from this picture, the craftsmanship allowing that feeling to haunt the screen at every turn. Wide shot compositions of muted colour palettes heighten the empty spaces throughout the town, adding to the nerve-wrecking feeling that these children could be anywhere. Larkin Seiple was also the cinematographer on 2022’s Everything Everywhere All At Once, and his approach here emphasises the chilling emptiness, whether literal or figurative, where these children should be. At times the camera follows the characters with erratic tracking shots, grounding us in the terror of the story. The music and sound design underscores this, their ominous beats generating a nail-biting symphony to the air of mystery. The skin-crawling anxiety that lingers in the atmosphere is reminiscent of Villeneuve’s Prisoners.
Cregger juggles various tones dexterously, finding an organicness in what may have otherwise been tonal confusion. The film’s inciting incident would invite disbelief as much as horror were it to actually happen, something Weapons does not shy away from. As answers remain evasive, characters have to contend with the strangeness of their circumstances, with many placed in either laugh or cry situations, particularly from Justine’s viewpoint. Even some of the imagery, namely a chase sequence towards the end of the picture, has a bizarreness to it that invites laughter as much as it does anxiety. A range of terrific performances allow the film to leap between its two tonal planes. Brolin and Garner are the standouts with their balancing acts of fear and anger, yet this should not devalue the efforts of young Christopher, Alden Ehrenreich as a struggling police officer and Amy Madigan, a late addition to the cast that proves deeply impressionable in her ability to unsettle.
Weapons, as great as it is, is also the victim of overhype given the excellent marketing campaign. The rugged character arcs are more in line with genuine tragedy, but this is perhaps also a consequence of the unusual storytelling choices. One particularly wonders if the film would’ve been more gripping if it had taken some more pages from Weir’s Picnic At Hanging Rock, where the horror came from the fundamental lack of answers. This mystery is definitively solved and while it’s a satisfying, even strong, resolution, the climax is abrupt. Meanwhile the atmosphere and themes are possibly undercut by the choice to deliver answers to this puzzle. Perhaps this is me criticising what the film isn’t rather than what it is, but for all its excellence, this critic can’t help but ponder on what could’ve been had it leaned a little heavier on its lack of convention.
Horror has had a banner year in 2025 thus far. Titles like Bring Her Back, Presence and especially Sinners have breathed new life into a genre that is already seeing a strong decade so far with gems like The Substance. Weapons will surely go down as one of 2025’s most inventive horrors. It boasts a haunting premise, great performances, spine-chilling direction and timely explorations of communal terror and fear of the unknown. Cregger and his team have delivered something as intricately woven as it is eerie in its setup and payoff. Weapons is a fitting title for, as a horror, it packs a mighty punch.
Weapons is in cinemas now
Rating: 




Director: Zach Cregger
Writer: Zach Cregger
Stars: Josh Brolin, Julia Garner, Alden Ehrenreich, Austin Abrams, Cary Christopher, Benedict Wong, Amy Madigan
Runtime: 128 minutes
Country: USA





